Skip to content
Permagora
All guides

Choosing and testing your ground (heavy metals)

Before planting, listen to the soil, what it bears, what it has seen, what it holds.

Level: Beginner 1 h of investigation + analysis time if needed

Introduction

A garden begins before the first spade stroke: with an investigation of the ground. Five minutes on Géorisques, ten minutes observing the neighbouring buildings, sometimes a soil analysis, these are the steps that then let you grow with peace of mind. This guide helps you know what is under your feet and decide in full knowledge of the facts.

Background

Urban, peri-urban and formerly industrial soils often carry traces of invisible pollution: lead from old paints (banned in France in 1949 for interior uses) or from petrol (banned in 2000), cadmium from phosphate fertilisers, arsenic from CCA-treated wood before 2004 or from old orchards sprayed with lead arsenate. These heavy metals do not break down in the soil, and some crops (lettuce, carrot, cabbage) accumulate them particularly.

Who this guide is for

Anyone starting a vegetable garden, especially in the city, on a plot whose history is uncertain, near a major road, or in an area of former industrial activity.

Why it matters

Because you cannot clean a contaminated soil after the fact. One hour of upfront investigation saves years of unsuitable crops, and lets you adopt the right strategies (raised beds, crop choice) where needed.

What to understand before starting

  • An internet connection to consult the public databases.
  • An hour of free time.
  • The exact address of the plot to study.
  • Ideally, the known history of the plot (former uses).

Detailed steps

  1. Step 1

    Consult Géorisques

    Go to georisques.gouv.fr. Enter the address of your plot. The national platform gathers on one map the natural risks, the known polluted sites (BASOL), the former potentially polluting activities (BASIAS) and the cadastral history. Everything is free and public. Note what you find.

  2. Step 2

    Check BASIAS specifically

    BASIAS lists hundreds of thousands of former industrial or service activities in France since 1850: petrol stations, mechanic workshops, printers, tanneries, gasworks, oil depots. Many are not in local memory but have left traces in the soil. An activity less than 100 m away can concern your plot.

  3. Step 3

    Observe the neighbouring buildings

    Houses built before 1949: a risk of lead in flaking paint that may have reached the garden soil. Old metal sheds, garages: possible traces of hydrocarbons, copper, zinc. Visible asbestos (fibre-cement roofs from before 1997): a further investigation for that distinct risk.

  4. Step 4

    Measure the distance to roads

    Lead from petrol contaminated soils in the immediate vicinity of major roads for 60 years. A plot less than 30 m from a busy major road deserves a soil analysis for lead. Beyond 100 m, the risk drops sharply.

  5. Step 5

    Decide whether a soil analysis is needed

    If Géorisques flags a nearby BASOL/BASIAS, if the plot is less than 30 m from a major road, if the buildings are old with flaking paint, or if you plan to grow for children under 6: an analysis is recommended. Otherwise, judge according to your own level of caution.

  6. Step 6

    Choose an analysis laboratory

    In France, several accredited laboratories offer soil analysis for heavy metals. SADEF (Aspach-le-Bas, Alsace), Auréa AgroSciences (several sites), INOVALYS, LAMS are references. Expect 60 to 200 € depending on the number of elements tested. Ask at minimum for: lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), arsenic (As). Add mercury and chromium if an industrial area is suspected.

  7. Step 7

    Take the sample correctly

    Make a composite sample: 5 to 10 sub-samples from different spots on the plot, 20 cm deep (the vegetable rooting zone), mixed in a clean bucket, from which you take 500 g for the laboratory. Clean plastic or stainless tools, no galvanised tools (zinc) or lead-handled ones.

  8. Step 8

    Read the results without panicking

    The laboratories give values in mg/kg of dry soil. There is no specific regulatory threshold for amateur gardening in France. Useful benchmarks: French background level Pb 10-30 mg/kg (BRGM); the order of 8 January 1998 on sewage-sludge spreading sets, for the receiving soil, Pb ≤ 100 mg/kg and Cd ≤ 2 mg/kg (this text sets no threshold for arsenic, there is no regulatory 'soil' value for As in France). Above these values, precautions are needed; beyond double them, reconsider the project or switch to raised beds.

Concrete examples

  • A community garden in Paris's 20th arrondissement: BASIAS reveals a former gasworks 50 m away → analysis → 280 mg/kg Pb → conversion to raised beds on geotextile.
  • A 19th-century country house in the Loire: flaking paint on the gable → analysis at the base of the façade → 450 mg/kg Pb → vegetable garden moved 10 m from the wall.
  • A rural plot with no history, 300 m from a secondary road: no analysis deemed necessary, a classic start.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Trusting a consumer colorimetric test: no kit is reliable for heavy metals, an ICP-MS laboratory is needed.
  • Analysing a single point: the soil is heterogeneous, a single sample may under- or over-estimate.
  • Confusing 'fertile soil' and 'healthy soil': a beautiful black soil can be heavily contaminated.
  • Forgetting arsenic in an old orchard: orchards sprayed with lead arsenate (until the 1950s) have durably contaminated soils.

Tips & best practices

  • If you hesitate to invest 150 €: the analysis is done once, and it guides every season that follows.
  • Cross-check several sources: testimony from elderly neighbours, old cadastral plans at the town hall or the departmental archives, IGN aerial photos (remonterletemps.ign.fr).
  • If you rent, make a simple written record: the analyses can serve you in case of dispute.

Frequently asked questions

Géorisques flags nothing, am I safe?
Not entirely. BASIAS only covers declared and inventoried activities. Many old lead paints and leaded petrol leave no trace in the public databases. If your plot is in an urban or peri-urban area, the history remains a factor to consider.
My analyses exceed the 100 mg/kg lead threshold, is it serious?
Not catastrophic, but it is a signal: you must adapt. See the guide 'Growing on doubtful soil'. Solutions exist: raised beds, choice of low-accumulating crops, moderate liming, rigorous washing of the vegetables. For young children (under 6), heightened caution.
Is a simple mulch enough to protect from metals?
No. Mulch protects from contaminated-dust splash, which is useful, but it does not reduce the availability of the metals to the roots. The fundamental solutions are amendment (organic matter, liming if acid soil) and above all physical separation with healthy soil (beds on geotextile).

Key takeaways

  • Géorisques + BASOL + BASIAS = a free investigation in 10 minutes before any analysis.
  • Distance to roads, age of buildings, cadastral history: three key clues.
  • A soil analysis costs 60-200 € and stays valid for years.
  • For heavy metals, only a laboratory can tell.

Sources

  • Arrêté du 8 janvier 1998 fixant les prescriptions techniques applicables aux épandages de boues sur les sols agricoles, annexe I, tableau 2 (valeurs limites dans les sols)
  • Kabata-Pendias, A. (2011). Trace Elements in Soils and Plants (4e éd.). Boca Raton : CRC Press.
  • Géorisques, portail de l'État sur les risques (georisques.gouv.fr)

See also